Skip to content
SBRSO
My Value
Latest · Nov. 17

The rent ordinance (No. 2026-6239) is suspended while the County verifies the referendum petition's signatures. On Nov. 17 the council introduced, 4–2, an extension of the rent freeze with a fair-return variance; an emergency version failed 4–2 (it needed five votes). Staff said it must be adopted by Dec. 1 to take effect before the freeze expires Dec. 31. See the timeline→Read the ordinance (PDF)

The Council Record

Every substantive statement on the rent ordinance from council members and staff — quoted verbatim from the official record and linked to the meeting video. Quotes are never edited or paraphrased; all commentary lives in the clearly separated analytical notes. Updated after every relevant council meeting.

Quotes that stand out

A few moments from the record, selected by SBRSO. Each is verbatim and linked to the meeting video; the full record below adds the analytical notes.

  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberSeptember 22, 2026Video · 4:25:56
    “That said, I do continue to have um sort of a fundamental overarching concern here that we are separating the drafting of this ordinance from the development of our understanding of how it's going to be implemented. Truthfully, that bifurcation does undermine my confidence in my own understanding of what I'm voting for.”

    Context: Harmon, who will vote yes, explains the reservation she carries into the vote.

    Full entry and note
  • Kristen SneddonCouncilmemberApril 7, 2026Video · 6:32:40
    “I knew that the 60% was the lowest number that was legally defensible from the research and … fully expected that that number would be negotiated upward … but something had to go in there as a placeholder.”

    Context: Sneddon explains, responding to Friedman, that the 60% figure in the earlier sample ordinance was a placeholder she expected to be negotiated higher.

    Full entry and note
  • Kristen SneddonCouncilmember (Mayor Pro Tem)September 22, 2026Video · 4:55:54
    “what I understood from tonight's meeting is how much far more complicated that is and expensive than I had previously understood. I thought it was a formula. You enter the numbers into the formula and that's how it was a little bit presented before. So tonight is sort of a a very different understanding for me than anything as I've understood it up until now.”

    Context: Clarifying her 3% suggestion for Harmon and counsel, Sneddon explains what changed her view.

    Full entry and note
  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberJanuary 13, 2026Video · 6:27:21
    “I truly don't buy the allegations that if we provide some breathing room to tenants, all of a sudden landlords won't be repairing units because you weren't doing it already. This sounds more like a threat than anything else, and it is simply not good governance for us to be reacting simply to threats.”

    Context: Santamaria rebuts landlord warnings that a rent freeze will reduce maintenance/repairs, citing her experience as a community organizer with deteriorated units.

    Full entry and note
  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberJuly 28, 2026Video · 7:01:44
    “Practically speaking, one of the things that has been weighing on me very heavily is there's the drafting of the ordinance, which I'm so glad that we're we're so focused on the the smallest words. That's really great. And there's this huge cavernous gulf between what we're talking about and how we're actually going to implement this program. And I have no idea how we're going to do that. And I to me that is where I'm what keeps me up at night is how we actually do this.”

    Context: Responding to staff's question about phasing the all-units rental registry, Harmon voices her core worry about the program.

    Full entry and note
  • Kristen SneddonCouncilmember (Mayor Pro Tem)September 29, 2026Video · 3:46:42
    “I have agreed to because there were the four votes needed. I have agreed to every additional iteration, every additional request. Every time it's come back, the goalpost moves and moves and moves. And now, now we're at a place where I'm not going to get to pass this after nine years of working on this. I wanted to pass it last week. … And because of how this has played out, frankly, because of how I feel I've been played, we're not passing it. I still would pass it today with with things that are far beyond what that initial one was. And I have taken it on good faith, trust that I was being given the most upto-date, the best standards.”

    Context: Sneddon, a co-sponsor, says she accepted every change to hold four votes and feels 'played,' but would still vote to pass the ordinance tonight.

    Full entry and note
  • Kelly McAdooCity AdministratorSeptember 22, 2026Video · 3:47:01
    “there is absolutely no way we would implement by Jul January 1st if we wait till after the fee study comes back.”

    Context: Responding to Santamaria's suggestion to bring the fee study back before adoption, McAdoo states the trade-off between knowing the cost and keeping the launch date.

    Full entry and note
  • Randy RowseMayorSeptember 22, 2026Video · 5:10:50
    “Was there a financial model that justifies 60% versus 3%. or was it just what we could legally get away with … going forward with this ordinance without even knowing what the base costs are for sure without this fee study isn't something that is good practice to begin with … this is not a very proud moment for this council.”

    Context: Closing deliberation before the votes, Rowse reacts to the last-minute 3% suggestion and the missing fee study.

    Full entry and note

The full record

192 quotes from 17 council meetings, newest first.

Quotes captured per council meeting, December 2025 → November 2026. Click a meeting to filter to it.

192 of 192
  • Barbara AndersenSenior Assistant to the City AdministratorNovember 17, 2026Video · 1:32:25
    “The urgency ordinance must be read in full, can be introduced and adopted this afternoon, and requires at least five votes. It is not subject to a referendum. The second option is the regular ordinance. It takes effect 30 days after adoption, needs no urgency findings, and requires four votes. It would be introduced this afternoon by title only and adopted at a later meeting. To be in effect before the moratorum [moratorium] expires on December 31st, the regular ordinance must be adopted by December 1st. Like any regular ordinance, it is subject to referendum.”

    Context: Presenting Item 15, Andersen sets out the two ways the council could extend the temporary rent-increase moratorium; staff recommended adopting both.

  • Barbara AndersenSenior Assistant to the City AdministratorNovember 17, 2026Video · 1:33:30
    “So unless council acts, the mortorium [moratorium] will end on December 31st. For the units covered today, that would leave a gap with no local limit on rent increases. You're to return to state regulations at 5% plus CPI or 10% whichever is lower.”

    Context: Explaining why an extension was before the council, Andersen describes what happens to covered units if the freeze lapses while the permanent ordinance is suspended.

  • Barbara AndersenSenior Assistant to the City AdministratorNovember 17, 2026Video · 1:34:27
    “So, if the referendum qualifies, it's staff commitment to um again move forward with a special election in the first half of the year. … Either way, if the referendum qualifies, staff will return with election options, deadlines, and costs.”

    Context: Describing the referendum process and closing her presentation, Andersen states staff's plan if the petition against Ordinance 2026-6239 qualifies.

  • Barbara AndersenSenior Assistant to the City AdministratorNovember 17, 2026Video · 1:38:52
    “First, the extension would keep the moratorum [moratorium] in place past December 31st. The current moratorum [moratorium] is the subject of a pending federal lawsuit and extending it could lead to additional claims either in that case or in a separate action. Second, the courts have said a city cannot get around a referendum by adopting essentially the same measure in another form. … Even so, that does not rule out a legal challenge. Third, property owners would continue to face a rent freeze with their costs such as insurance, utilities, maintenance, and taxes as they continue to rise. Their only avenue for relief would be the variance petition, which requires them to show that an increase is needed for a fair return.”

    Context: Andersen presents staff's considerations against extending the freeze, after the considerations in favor.

  • John DoimasCity AttorneyNovember 17, 2026Video · 6:42:53
    “there is case law that especially recent case law that came out last year that distinguishes that if you maintain a status quo while you wait for the period of a referendum that is a legally defensible action to take. And that is what we are relying upon … It is distinguishable from the RSO. It does not contain any of the mechanisms. Does not contain a rent board. Does not contain a a CPI cap.”

    Context: Santamaria, who had put her questions to the City Attorney by name, asks whether the City is required to maintain the status quo during a referendum.

  • Dan HentschkeAssistant City AttorneyNovember 17, 2026Video · 6:45:43
    “We do not include a standard for fair rate of return because it's different for each property and each property owner. In the in the RSO, what we did include was maintenance of net operating income as a presumptive standard for a fair return.”

    Context: Santamaria asks why the extension's variance has no single definition of a fair rate of return; the City Attorney hands the question to the Assistant City Attorney, who drafted the extension and answered from online.

  • Dan HentschkeAssistant City AttorneyNovember 17, 2026Video · 6:48:02
    “One of the very the the difficulties that we have in this context is fair rate fair rate of return is a standard that's been used by the courts many many times but there is no specific definition of what that necessarily has to be and we're not trying to create it here.”

    Context: Answering Santamaria's paraphrase that the fair return is 'subjective to each situation', Hentschke calls it 'an objective standard that varies' by property, then describes the difficulty.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberNovember 17, 2026Video · 6:49:10
    “from everything we heard from the public the the emergency right now the way I understand it's not the referendum it's the fact that a drastic rent sudden rent spike of 8.6% 6% would inevitably displace potentially masses of people. And that's that's what I'm seeing as the the the reason for for us adopting it as an urgency emergency ordinance.”

    Context: Santamaria asks the City Attorney to confirm the basis for adopting the extension as an urgency ordinance.

  • John DoimasCity AttorneyNovember 17, 2026Video · 6:49:57
    “But when it comes to the legality, if it's reviewed by a court, let's just say a court won't accept a bare declaration of urgency. There has to be some supporting fact. … a court will not normally secondguess when you do articulate those facts or the reason they give great deference to the legislative body”

    Context: Answering Santamaria's question 'for our city attorneys' on the basis for urgency, Doimas explains Charter Section 511 and the standard a court applies.

  • John DoimasCity AttorneyNovember 17, 2026Video · 7:01:00
    “To answer your question, the RSO does have a cap, right? It has one. The moratorum [moratorium] does not. So if you have a cap, that is something that's changing the status quo is acting similar to the RSO.”

    Context: Sneddon asks whether other changes, such as a 3% allowance, could or should be made to the freeze in the interim; the City Attorney takes 'a first stab' and invites Hentschke to elaborate.

  • Dan HentschkeAssistant City AttorneyNovember 17, 2026Video · 7:02:06
    “When we talk about extending the status quo, we're talking about the moratorum [moratorium] that is currently in place as we speak today and extending that moratorum [moratorium] until really until the voters have an opportunity to decide at an election probably within the next 6 months. … we did consider can we add things to this and we came to the conclusion that no we could not.”

    Context: Invited by the City Attorney to elaborate on Sneddon's question, Hentschke, who drafted the extension, explains its purpose and the variance.

  • Randy RowseMayorNovember 17, 2026Video · 7:04:32
    “And if we get challenged legally, and I kind of assume we are being challenged legally, um, we're kind of flying blind in a fact-free situation. We're making assumptions about the number of units that are even going to fall into this. And we're also making the assumption that, you know, we're speculating that the landlords would go to the max automatically. … We can't provide any numbers. we can just provide this kind of anecdotal fear that this just might happen.”

    Context: After Sneddon's questions, Mayor Rowse asks the City Attorney, by name, how a judge would view urgency findings made without data.

  • John DoimasCity AttorneyNovember 17, 2026Video · 7:05:35
    “Honorable mayor, you as I mentioned before, you know, a judge would give great deference to council making this decision. … that council is perfectly appropriate for them to be predictive. You don't have to sit there and wait for the incidents to happen and then act. … there's no guarantee ever when we're talking about law.”

    Context: The City Attorney answers the Mayor's question about how a judge would treat urgency findings made without data.

  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberNovember 17, 2026Video · 7:10:08
    “And I think um as to a regular ordinance or an urgency ordinance to me an urgency ordinance is is certainly called for in this moment. The risks of displacement um the shocks to our community um the potential shocks are extreme. … It is simply about maintaining the state of play as it currently exists between now and um it looks like June when that vote will occur though of course that's a separate decision point.”

    Context: Opening deliberation, Harmon explains her support for extending the freeze and for the urgency option.

  • Kristen SneddonCouncilmember (Mayor Pro Tem)November 17, 2026Video · 7:11:08
    “I also will be voting to support it. And just the comment that you know ironically if we had had this option to extend this before we could have taken more time with the RSO and now that we're in the mode of referendum we can't make adjustments to the RSO and so it's um a very frustrating um position to be in”

    Context: Recognized after Harmon, Mayor Pro Tem Sneddon, co-author of the September 2025 memo that began the ordinance, states her vote.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberNovember 17, 2026Video · 7:15:02
    “we have to remember the constitutional fair rate of return uh petition will be there for this moratorium. So there is an option for property owners who are legitimately operating under that constitutional fair rate of return to calculate it. You know SBRPA I know has a great calculator on how to find your fair rate of return.”

    Context: In her deliberation remarks, Santamaria describes the relief available to owners under the extension.

  • Oscar GutierrezCouncilmemberNovember 17, 2026Video · 7:16:50
    “But you all didn't want to budge an inch. And I even warned you all that if you don't work with me, then you're not going to like what's going to end up happening later. And here we are.”

    Context: Gutierrez answers public commenters who said property owners had not been invited to the table, citing the council's housing crisis ad hoc committee.

  • Eric FriedmanCouncilmemberNovember 17, 2026Video · 7:17:46
    “So, my recollection is slightly different and the minutes of our previous meeting in April probably reflect this, but Mike Jordan and I in April both said we don't support it for many of the reasons, but we also said that we would be willing to work with the majority to find something if it wasn't the 60% of CPI. and that wasn't taken up at the time.”

    Context: Recognized after Gutierrez, Friedman disputes the account that property owners and the minority would not compromise.

  • Randy RowseMayorNovember 17, 2026Video · 7:19:40
    “We failed legislatively. That's why there's going to be a referendum on this. Um the idea that we put in a quote unquote safety valve is really small comfort to a small landlord. … I still think it's very speculative to assume that all those consequences of us not doing something are going to come to fruition. We don't even have the numbers. We don't have the facts. We don't have the data.”

    Context: Taking his turn after Friedman, Mayor Rowse explains his vote against both versions of the extension.

  • John DoimasCity AttorneyNovember 17, 2026Video · 7:22:16
    “The reason we have that structured that way is um if it's voted as an urgency and as voted as a regular ordinance if for some reason to go to your point, Mr. Mayor, the urgency point was still held invalid, the other one would remain. So, I would recommend any motion at least contain both so we could have a vote on those for tonight.”

    Context: As the Mayor turns to a motion, the City Attorney asks that the council vote on both the urgency and the regular ordinance.

  • Barbara AndersenSenior Assistant to the City AdministratorOctober 27, 2026Video · 3:21:03
    “The ordinance amends five existing sections and adds six new sections. Several of these are technical but a number are significant policy changes that the public has not previously seen in ordinance form.”

    Context: Opening her presentation of the October 8 introduction draft of the Chapter 26.50 Just Cause amendments, after naming herself and noting that the Assistant City Attorney was absent, Andersen describes the draft's scope.

  • Barbara AndersenSenior Assistant to the City AdministratorOctober 27, 2026Video · 3:35:28
    “As anticipated, the ordinance assigns new duties to the office of housing and community vitality. … Staff anticipates absorbing these within the staffing and resources proposed for the rent stabilization program. If these duties strain existing staffing, staff will return to council with a fee adjustment possibly or a general fund appropriation request.”

    Context: Closing her presentation, Andersen lists the administrative duties the amendments assign to the City Administrator's Office of Housing and Community Vitality.

  • Barbara AndersenSenior Assistant to the City AdministratorOctober 27, 2026Video · 3:36:31
    “I also want to clarify that these are amendments are not staff recommendations. These amendments were proposed by tenant advocates and directed by council for staff to incorporate.”

    Context: At the end of her presentation, just before public comment, Andersen separates the source of the amendments from staff's recommended action, which was to introduce the ordinance.

  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberOctober 27, 2026Video · 5:01:15
    “Can you speak a little bit to the relationship between these ordinances and the implications for this ordinance um if the referendum that is currently ongoing is to pass? I guess it's sort of a double that's not a double if it passes the RSO unfortunately would go away.”

    Context: Recognized for questions, Harmon asks the City Attorney, whom she addresses by name, how the just cause amendments relate to the rent stabilization ordinance adopted October 6.

  • John DoimasCity AttorneyOctober 27, 2026Video · 5:02:07
    “Um that issue regarding the RSO and the potential referendum was not at play. … So there are some references specifically to the RSO. If there is a uh referendum, if that suspends the RSO, that suspends those provisions in place.”

    Context: Answering Harmon's question (q156), the City Attorney says the two ordinances are distinct but that the just cause draft refers to Chapter 26.90 in several places.

  • Kristen SneddonCouncilmember (Mayor Pro Tem)October 27, 2026Video · 5:03:34
    “So there are a couple different places where this references the RSO um and also uh the capital improvement plans in particular and the the cost of rerenting. So if that is in referendum state then this is referring to something that doesn't doesn't exist.”

    Context: Recognized by the chair after the City Attorney's answer to Harmon, Sneddon says the referendum was her question too and follows up.

  • Eric FriedmanCouncilmemberOctober 27, 2026Video · 5:10:41
    “But then there's the flip side, and you and I talked about this, is it creates a loophole the way it's written, that somebody could come in and and say the rent is $3,000 a month for the contract and then just decide not to pay that and pay less every single month. Say they decide to just pay $300 a month less every month until it gets to that 3,000.”

    Context: Recognized by the chair, Friedman opens his questions, some of which he says 'are going to require city attorney,' on the draft's rule that no eviction for non-payment may proceed unless at least one full month's rent is owed.

  • Randy RowseMayorOctober 27, 2026Video · 5:24:17
    “Well, my concern is since we're proposing such something with such a major economic impact that we have a lot of those kind of questions out there that we don't really know what the final analysis is going to be.”

    Context: During council questions, after staff tell him there will be templates and an information guide for owners, the Mayor turns to what is still unknown about the program.

  • Randy RowseMayorOctober 27, 2026Video · 5:26:30
    “But is it fair to say that right now as we look at this program we're dealing with hypotheticals as opposed to statistics in terms of making a major program the way we're talking about it outlined today? … before that we know what the the fate of the RSO is and also without knowing exactly what it is we're trying to cure for.”

    Context: After staff describe the eviction data available to the City, the Mayor asks whether the council is legislating without statistics on the problem.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberOctober 27, 2026Video · 5:33:25
    “So, I do think there's a lot of good things in this draft to celebrate, but it's not ready. So, we do need to make some amendments and some cleanup. … If the ordinance is paused uh through the referendum, it may be worth it to spell out the capital improvement plan into the just cause ordinance so that it's not pointing into a void, but rather pointing to something specific so everyone is clear on what the both the landlord and the tenant are responsible for regardless of what happens with the RSO and the referendum.”

    Context: Recognized first for deliberative comments, the lead sponsor of the rent ordinance lists the changes she wants before the just cause amendments go forward.

  • Barbara AndersenSenior Assistant to the City AdministratorOctober 27, 2026Video · 5:43:33
    “Council member Santa Maria [Santamaria] and Mayor Russ [Rowse], I apologize because this is not the time for staff comments, but I wanted to clarify. You stated that that the Ellis protections would match state law and nothing more but then that would exclude the proposed amendment of not evicting people during the school year which does not match Ellis Act amendments.”

    Context: Immediately after Santamaria's deliberative comments, Andersen interrupts the order of business to point out a conflict in her direction; the City Attorney, recognized next, says 'Miss Anderson beat me to it.'

  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberOctober 27, 2026Video · 5:51:09
    “Um, I would like to avoid another referendum here. I'm sorry. I don't want to miss the forest for the trees here and to say I'm unwilling to compromise on anything and then for this to be referendum just like the other ordinance and then we lose it all together. … the threat of a referendum is not a spectre. It is a reality and I am trying to get to yes.”

    Context: In her deliberative comments Harmon proposes concessions to property owners on the draft (a backstop on the one-month rule, a narrower school-year defense, registered agents in place of trust-beneficiary lists) and says why.

  • Kristen SneddonCouncilmember (Mayor Pro Tem)October 27, 2026Video · 5:52:50
    “Um, so I think there are things that we could pass tonight or at least give direction to bring back. I mean, it wouldn't be introduced tonight … Um with the RSO referendum in limbo, um I have serious concerns about references to a capital improvement plan. … with the fee study not back yet, I would also be concerned with this particular draft referencing the capital improvement plans and the other program until we know”

    Context: Recognized after Harmon, Sneddon gives her deliberative comments, separating what she would act on from what she would hold.

  • Kristen SneddonCouncilmember (Mayor Pro Tem)October 27, 2026Video · 5:54:55
    “part of part of my hesitancy too is on how much the relocation assistance is and how many um, months it covers because if a RSO is in place, then a owner is not getting as much return and has less to give for relocation. But if there's no RSO in place, then I feel like that should be the strongest possible amount for relocation because um you're losing both if that makes sense. So both of those hinge to me on whether the RSO is in place or not.”

    Context: Continuing her deliberative comments, Sneddon explains why she would not yet set relocation-assistance amounts in the just cause ordinance.

  • Mike JordanCouncilmemberOctober 27, 2026Video · 6:00:59
    “It's pretty clear what's been driving this boat. … Well, there's 10 new brand new items in here, too. and council didn't see those before today either. … as you just heard, the the the danger of a referendum is really clear.”

    Context: Recognized by the chair for deliberative comments, Jordan responds to a tenant-union speaker's complaint in public comment that provisions had been dropped without council discussion.

  • Kelly McAdooCity AdministratorOctober 27, 2026Video · 6:06:38
    “I think when we bring this back, what might be helpful is just maybe doing sideby-side comparisons of Ellis Act, what was in this proposal draft, and then maybe some best practices from other cities. And I mean, I think we've heard some consensus on some items. Clearly not ready to introduce anything tonight.”

    Context: After the City Attorney offers to review the provisions that go beyond the Ellis Act, the City Administrator describes how staff would bring the item back; Andersen later credits 'city administrator McAdoo's point that we can do that analysis.'

  • Randy RowseMayorOctober 27, 2026Video · 6:18:32
    “so uh I realize we're not going to move forward with this particular thing. Doesn't look like it tonight. you guys have creative ideas, but man, this needs a lot more work. I think Mr. Jordan's exactly right. This really wasn't inclusive in terms of a process. … I stamped my little feet to Mr. Dyus [Doimas] a few days before this, but that was already the way too late.”

    Context: Closing the deliberation before inviting a motion, the Mayor gives his own comments on the draft and the process that produced it.

  • Kelly McAdooCity AdministratorOctober 27, 2026Video · 6:19:33
    “I don't know that it would be helpful tonight. I think we need to I think we need to go back and do some legal research. We need to talk with the stakeholder groups and and just I'm just going to be realistic. There is no way that this is coming back before the end of the year. … um even in spite of the pending RSO referenda, we still have to go forward and do all of the implementation steps just in case it doesn't qualify for the ballot because we would then be obligated to implement it January 1st. … it will also give us some clarity as to where we are with the rent stabilization petition if we come back after the first of the year because by that time we'll know if it has qualified um for a special uh for a ballot, a special election.”

    Context: Santamaria asks whether staff need votes on the councilmembers' various requests; the City Administrator answers, and the City Attorney then builds on 'Miss McAdoo's point' that no motion is needed.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberOctober 27, 2026Video · 6:22:44
    “the the the letter that we got from the from the edgerly from the baddest foundation what what I you know in speaking to these tenants. It's correct. So the tenant portion is not being raised but the housing authority uh portion is and that's what we were trying to avoid is like we have now just added another expense on the housing authority. They now have to cover an 8% increase because we didn't cover the folks um with section 8 vouchers.”

    Context: Closing her comments, Santamaria answers the letter Friedman had read into the record from the foundation that owns the Edgerly, a senior residence (the captions garble its name), which says the 8.6% increase falls on the Housing Authority's share of the rent, not the tenants'.

  • John DoimasCity AttorneyOctober 27, 2026Video · 6:24:31
    “the the RSO had a competing outside issue because we had the moratorum [moratorium] um and so that we don't have that same pressure as you said we have just cause already in the books. … Uh but there isn't an outside influence or anything that would have that clock ticking where we or I would advise the sooner the better.”

    Context: Sneddon asks the City Attorney, by name, to frame why the just cause amendments are not as urgent as the rent ordinance was.

  • John DoimasCity AttorneyOctober 6, 2026Video · 0:22:45
    “So we we have two options. The safest course is to bring it back for introduction which would be the 27th is our next meeting and then uh for adoption on the 10th. um many times that we have reintroduced at the same meeting some changes and then brought it back for adoption which means it would be intro reintroduced today and be brought back the 27th. … the safest course always is the first one I mentioned. Uh and then also uh since it's being pulled if it is pulled from consent I should say uh then I would ask we also whatever happens make a separate motion on the waiver of reading uh as well.”

    Context: During agenda changes, before the consent calendar, the City Administrator flags that council may want changes to the ordinance up for adoption and asks the City Attorney to speak.

  • Randy RowseMayorOctober 6, 2026Video · 0:23:32
    “So when something comes through on consent, I think it's everyone's understanding that it's been heard at hearing and it's been decided and then the consent is a second reading and it's voted up or down. To have a separate hearing today to discuss changes seems to me that it wouldn't have been properly noticed to all the interested parties that might want to participated. … going forward, what does consent actually mean then? Is it is it not a second reading? Is it a second hearing? It is a second hearing. Shouldn't there be full notice?”

    Context: The chair's question to the City Attorney immediately after counsel described the two options for changing the ordinance at adoption.

  • John DoimasCity AttorneyOctober 6, 2026Video · 0:24:40
    “There is some flexibility in terms of the ability of council when as long as it's noticed and the public knows what the item is about. If there are desire to make lastm minute changes, council should be allowed to do that. They can't be like stuck in that foundation. But that means if they want to make the changes, then it's the procedure I just mentioned that you come back then for introduction and then you go for adoption. So the notice issue is taken care of that you're primarily concerned about because the public is informed about what is before the council today”

    Context: Answering the Mayor's question whether a floor amendment at a consent-calendar second reading is properly noticed.

  • Kristen SneddonCouncilmember (Mayor Pro Tem)October 6, 2026Video · 0:31:45
    “I have a question for city attorney if it would be possible just for the first year of implementation, not necessarily a change to the ordinance, to have that first year be at a 3% cap with the intention that um any changes would not have to have freezes and that it would allow for the new council um to be able to have that”

    Context: Having pulled Item 5 from consent, Sneddon opens the pulled-item discussion with a question to the City Attorney about a flat 3% cap for the first year.

  • John DoimasCity AttorneyOctober 6, 2026Video · 0:32:14
    “Um yeah, I mean it would be possible, it would require a change in one particular section of the ordinance and then some other matching ones, but um from a from a legal standpoint to amend the amend the ordinance. Yes, you could you could do that.”

    Context: The City Attorney's direct answer to Sneddon's question whether a first-year 3% cap is possible.

  • Kelly McAdooCity AdministratorOctober 6, 2026Video · 0:32:38
    “I think are that would require the reintroduction of the ordinance if the council wishes to move forward with that today. Um, and so if you want to make that motion now and have a discussion on it, I think that's up to the pleasure of the council. Um, and see if there's appetite to make that change. and and so that that would then we would reintroduce the ordinance today and then the adoption would be postponed until October 27th.”

    Context: Sneddon asks whether this is the moment to make her motion; the City Administrator explains what the motion would do to the schedule.

  • Kristen SneddonCouncilmember (Mayor Pro Tem)October 6, 2026Video · 0:33:06
    “Um and I'm not sure if there's support or not, but I would like to make that motion that for the first year of implementation of the rent stabilization ordinance that it be capped at 3%.”

    Context: The motion as made. Harmon seconds it 'out of deference to my colleague' (q133).

  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberOctober 6, 2026Video · 0:33:20
    “Just a procedural question on this. If um this motion goes forward and is not successful, we can then return to the second reading of the ordinance as presented on today's agenda and make that vote. That is that correct? … All right. Then I'm happy um out of deference to my colleague to second that motion.”

    Context: Harmon checks with the City Attorney that a failed 3% motion would not block adoption as presented, then seconds the motion.

  • Mike JordanCouncilmemberOctober 6, 2026Video · 0:33:54
    “I'm perplexed because in my private conversations with the city attorney, you've already expressed concern over um similar structures of changes that would push back u consideration two or three weeks and extend the freeze. … any extension of several weeks continues to load additional potential legal liability on us in regards to the freeze. So, I'm I guess without anybody else bringing it up, that seems a little remiss to not uh hear some um uh information on that.”

    Context: Jordan asks the City Attorney to put on the record the moratorium-liability concern he says counsel had raised privately.

  • John DoimasCity AttorneyOctober 6, 2026Video · 0:35:00
    “it's a very fair question and my position is not changed on that. um that hanging over um the RSO is the moratorum [moratorium] and um I think you said it last time when there's deliberation there is a shelf life. I think that term is appropriate um because the longer you go with a moratorium the more risk it has that is clear and that hasn't changed”

    Context: The City Attorney's answer to Jordan, on the record, about the legal risk of extending the rent freeze.

  • John DoimasCity AttorneyOctober 6, 2026Video · 0:35:39
    “because we have done this in the past my preference because of that liability and hanging over my head would be for reintroduction today's mad said to um then bring it back that would be reinduction [reintroduction] today on October 6th then to bring back for adoption on October 27th with the goal of making those timelines. … it's not like the ordinance becomes effective today. We still must come back now for adoption because today it's scheduled for adoption. That means we still must come back 21 days from now.”

    Context: Continuing his answer to Jordan, the City Attorney states his own preference if council changes the ordinance.

  • Eric FriedmanCouncilmemberOctober 6, 2026Video · 0:36:58
    “we're making this is a substantive change that was discussed back in April. We voted on it. Back in July, we voted on that on the on on keeping the 60% and even last week in a very substantive hearing that had many members of the public here in the chambers participating online and we came to the conclusion where we are today to adopt the ordinance. They're not here today because it's on the consent calendar. … when most members of the public see that there's a consent item after you've already had a substantive hearing, they don't think we're going to rehear it or make this big of a change.”

    Context: Friedman, recognized after counsel's answer to Jordan, objects to changing the cap on a consent-calendar second reading.

  • John DoimasCity AttorneyOctober 6, 2026Video · 0:38:42
    “Um I an argument can be made that anything change in this is substantive. The counterargument that you'd have to rely on is that the ordinance still talks about 3% or 60% CPI or whatever is less is the number. And we're we're talking about something for the first year. It still has that 3% floor. … can I give a guarantee on that today? No. I'm trying to take a basically a complex ed issue and trying to thread the needle as I could.”

    Context: The City Attorney's reply to Friedman on whether a first-year 3% cap is a substantive change requiring full renoticing.

  • Eric FriedmanCouncilmemberOctober 6, 2026Video · 0:39:47
    “I I feel one that last week it was mentioned the goalposts were being moved. It feels like they're being moved again. The public's not here to opine on this, so I'm not going to be able to support this.”

    Context: Friedman's closing remark after the City Attorney's answer, declaring his position on the first-year 3% motion.

  • Mike JordanCouncilmemberOctober 6, 2026Video · 0:40:02
    “I won't uh lie that I think it's actually a positive move, not one that I haven't talked about. In fact, we sat here a week ago and whispered amongst ourselves on was it possible while supporters were trying to eat their own for an hour and we had to sit here through that. Um but it's uh at the same time all I heard last week was moving the goalposts and this has been a process of 10 some months or 11 some months in the making where it started bizarrely with an entire ordinance”

    Context: Jordan's comments on the motion, recognized after Friedman. He says the 3% idea has merit but objects to how it arrived.

  • Mike JordanCouncilmemberOctober 6, 2026Video · 0:40:52
    “that entire ordinance has been slapped in on a twoperson memo. And um the goalposts have moved repeatedly over that time with the same majority voting to move those goalposts each time. Um it just uh seems like uh people can't make up their mind. … the freeze is was that it rose to the level of an immediate health and safety need and we were granted a period of time to to give up normal legislative process to uh to assert a right under those regards. And then the stewardship of this body hasn't even been to recognize that those were the findings we made and use that time.”

    Context: Jordan continues: the ordinance's origin in a two-member memo, the shifting goalposts, and the emergency findings behind the moratorium.

  • Mike JordanCouncilmemberOctober 6, 2026Video · 0:42:20
    “again, I won't I won't say it's not a a nibble at the monster of the actual legislative action to soften it, but I I I just think it's been a bad process and poor governance to get us to where we are today.”

    Context: Jordan's conclusion on the first-year 3% motion.

  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberOctober 6, 2026Video · 0:42:56
    “I I also agree and can see the point of both my colleagues that there's some efficacy in the sort of smoothing effect of a year one implementation. And then so I I hear that and I also feel um the concerns that have been articulated around public participation around the increasing litigation exposure uh visa v the moratorum [moratorium] the delay the public trust issues of which I think we have long since passed the point when the public has trust um in us”

    Context: Harmon, recognized after Jordan, weighs the first-year cap she seconded against notice, litigation exposure and public trust.

  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberOctober 6, 2026Video · 0:43:30
    “So, I do want to just ask if there's a way to thread the needle a little bit here today, which is to pass the ordinance as it's presented and then come back via the implementation plan to adopt whether it's this council or the next council a year one change or or whatever the whatever the suggestion might be at that time, but to adopt today, but then to come back whether it's through um I don't even know what the mechanism would be, but some kind of implementation plan that um contemplates this. Um so we don't necessarily have to do it via ordinance.”

    Context: Harmon's proposed middle path: adopt tonight and make any first-year change later through an implementation plan rather than an ordinance.

  • Kelly McAdooCity AdministratorOctober 6, 2026Video · 0:44:16
    “I I say I would say no and I'll look to the city attorney to because it it is language that is included in the ordinance. It would have to be an amendment to the ordinance. So if we are going to do something different, the ordinance needs to be amended.”

    Context: The City Administrator answers Harmon's question whether a first-year cap change could be made through an implementation plan. The speaker is not named in the captions; the attribution rests on content (the answer defers to the City Attorney, manages the agenda and repeats her 0:32:38 reintroduction answer).

  • Kristen SneddonCouncilmember (Mayor Pro Tem)October 6, 2026Video · 0:45:08
    “I I was just going to say I'm ready to vote and not further discuss it with the understanding that if it's better to adopt today um and leave this to a new council when the fee study comes back and um implementation strategies. This is something I have mentioned from the beginning and have left it an opening for anybody else to have made the motion and I thought this is my last chance to do so and if there isn't support there isn't support and we adopt today and I think we can take a simple vote on it and be done.”

    Context: After staff's answers, the maker of the 3% motion says she is ready to vote and will accept adoption as presented if the motion lacks support.

  • Randy RowseMayorOctober 6, 2026Video · 0:45:41
    “I'm personally particularly frustrated because we've gone and tortured this thing how many times? And I appreciate Mr. Dis's [Doimas's] comments about it, but I still believe that the consent hearing is in fact an up or down situation that a new hearing should have proper notice and the kind of participation that we always insist on for other kinds of hearings. So, here we are in the situation where we've been in this ricochet room and the proponents were complaining about the ricochet room themselves last time and now we're going to do it again.”

    Context: The chair's own comments on the motion, after Sneddon says she is ready to vote.

  • Randy RowseMayorOctober 6, 2026Video · 0:46:23
    “we're sitting there talking about the the moratorum [moratorium] and the legal ramifications. We're rubbing salt into self-inflicted wounds is what we're doing. We're the ones that push this thing up against the 11th hour. And now the public's out there going, "What are we doing?" And uh it's a darn good question.”

    Context: The chair's closing words before a staff member reminds him that public comment must be taken before the vote.

  • Randy RowseMayorOctober 6, 2026Video · 0:50:43
    “I'm going to ask that people try to keep these brief because we end up with a lot of And I'm going to cut off the, uh, the new slips and new hands raised on this item as well because this was not anticipated to turn into a hearing.”

    Context: The chair, three minutes into public comment on the pulled item, closes the list of speakers.

  • Kristen SneddonCouncilmember (Mayor Pro Tem)October 6, 2026Video · 1:10:28
    “I would like to amend my motion to adopt today.”

    Context: The first words from the dais after public comment closes. Harmon seconds; the Clerk restates it as the motion to approve the recommended action for Item 5.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberOctober 6, 2026Video · 1:10:54
    “I just want to thank you all. Genuinely, thank you. I you hear the public loud and clear. Let's adopt now. We It's not locking us into anything. We can always amend.”

    Context: Santamaria's only remarks during the item, between the amended motion and the vote.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberOctober 6, 2026Video · 4:38:02
    “let me let me ask first about how this how this ordinance is going to interact with the rental registry and I know that that may not have been considered yet since the rental registry it doesn't exist yet, right? But we know that it's coming and we have the rent civilization [stabilization] ordinance adopted today. The rental registry will be formed. Um, my understanding was that it could be used as a way to help regulate short-term rentals, the the registry itself.”

    Context: Three and a half hours later, during council questions on Item 13 (the short-term vacation rental ordinance), Santamaria asks how that ordinance will use the rental registry adopted earlier in the meeting.

  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberSeptember 29, 2026Video · 3:21:39
    “Right now, there are 1,518 voucher holders on section on the section 8 waiting list in the city of Santa Barbara. That's 1,518 people who deeply need this subsidy who cannot find a unit that will accept their voucher. And the shocking thing about that number is that it doesn't even come close to actually reflecting the real urgency of the need. New applications for housing vouchers have been closed in this city since June of 2023.”

    Context: Opening council deliberation after public comment, Harmon explains why the Section 8 exemption matters to her, citing the Housing Authority's closed waiting list.

  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberSeptember 29, 2026Video · 3:23:12
    “Practically speaking, layering more bureaucracy on top of what already exists does almost nothing to improve habitability while it does quite a lot to disincentivize landlords from participating in the program altogether. … It will be cold comfort to the voucher holder that that same apartment, now $4,000 a month, no subsidy accepted, is only going to go up by $81 next year. It will be cold comfort because that tenant just won't be there at all. The risk is profound and it is not one that I am willing to take.”

    Context: Harmon's core argument against covering Section 8 tenancies: added RSO complexity drives landlords out of the voucher program, and a capped rent is no substitute for the subsidy.

  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberSeptember 29, 2026Video · 3:27:40
    “very critically in the background of this conversation is the expiration of the tenant rent increase moratorum [moratorium]. Every day that we do not pass this ordinance, we increase the city's risk. We increase the city's litigation exposure and we also increase the risk that the moratorum [moratorium] will somehow lift with tenants bearing that consequence. I don't see any justification for those risks. We all know this ordinance will need to be shaped and molded in the months and years to come. Pressing pause now, even for a few weeks, is a gamble with no justifiable upside.”

    Context: Closing her remarks, Harmon ties passage tonight to the rent-increase moratorium's expiration and the city's litigation exposure, and says the ordinance will be revised after it passes.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberSeptember 29, 2026Video · 3:30:03
    “I just want to correct some things for the record. The 1,500 the the the folks on the wait list, that's not a wait list waiting for a unit because landlords won't give it to them because they have a secondary voucher. Those are people waiting for a voucher and the housing authority doesn't have the money to issue those vouchers because we've seen cuts from the federal government. … Landlords want to participate. The data on the housing authority dashboard is 91.96% of vouchers are being used.”

    Context: Santamaria rebuts Harmon's waiting-list argument with Housing Authority dashboard data, reframing the 1,500 as people waiting for vouchers rather than for landlords.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberSeptember 29, 2026Video · 3:31:49
    “There is zero data that shows that inclusion or partial inclusion of deedrestricted [deed-restricted] affordable housing section 8 voucher holder tenants is going to diminish the participation. The data shows otherwise. Again, San Francisco has an ordinance like what we're trying to propose today. And it's not decreasing their usage of the vouchers. There's only 11 out there.”

    Context: Continuing her rebuttal, Santamaria asserts there is no evidence that covering Section 8 tenants reduces landlord participation and cites San Francisco as the model.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberSeptember 29, 2026Video · 3:39:49
    “One of the conversation or some of the conversations I've been having with property owners is allowing them to consider the capital improvements they made since December 16 of 2025 to be eligible for pass through because during the rent freeze that those are the ones that you're making, right? You're making the ne only the necessary things … We want to allow a property owner to recoup some at least some of those costs for those necessary repairs. So, I do think it would be important that we clarify when a capital improvement um is eligible for pass through.”

    Context: Santamaria raises owner-side fixes: letting capital improvements made during the rent freeze qualify for pass-through, and clarifying when a capital improvement is eligible.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberSeptember 29, 2026Video · 3:40:47
    “the cost is a really big thing and I know that we don't have our fee study yet. The last number we had heard was it was roughly $154 per unit per year. That number is subject to change. But I also want us to clarify that I think the numbers that were cited last week, I don't know how accurate they were. So, I know I know staff mentioned something about a couple like 20-ish thousand dollars for some things, but I don't think we know those numbers yet. So, I just want to clarify that these are not known numbers that we should be attaching ourselves to. … one of the things that I've seen in other cities is the combination of the capital improvement pass through petitions and the fair rate of return petitions into one.”

    Context: Santamaria questions the per-petition cost figures staff cited on September 22, notes the fee study is still pending, and proposes merging the two owner petition types.

  • Kristen SneddonCouncilmember (Mayor Pro Tem)September 29, 2026Video · 3:45:18
    “in the sample one it was uh capped at an increase of 60% of inflation with no ceiling. Now it has a 3% ceiling. Second our sample let owners recover those costs over time. This version limits them to a short list of approved projects. It caps the pass through with $100 a month even for something as large as a seismic retrofit. Third, there are at least six of these, just to name a few. Our sample ordinance on the fair return was intended to be a simple form-based calculation like many other places do. Now, it requires a hearing and a prepundonderance [preponderance] of evidence and enlisting an economist, something that no tenant can do.”

    Context: Sneddon itemizes how the ordinance has changed from the sample ordinance she and Santamaria sponsored: the cap ceiling, the pass-through limits and the fair-return process.

  • Kristen SneddonCouncilmember (Mayor Pro Tem)September 29, 2026Video · 3:46:42
    “I have agreed to because there were the four votes needed. I have agreed to every additional iteration, every additional request. Every time it's come back, the goalpost moves and moves and moves. And now, now we're at a place where I'm not going to get to pass this after nine years of working on this. I wanted to pass it last week. … And because of how this has played out, frankly, because of how I feel I've been played, we're not passing it. I still would pass it today with with things that are far beyond what that initial one was. And I have taken it on good faith, trust that I was being given the most upto-date, the best standards.”

    Context: Sneddon, a co-sponsor, says she accepted every change to hold four votes and feels 'played,' but would still vote to pass the ordinance tonight.

  • Eric FriedmanCouncilmemberSeptember 29, 2026Video · 3:52:45
    “But the housing authority doesn't have traditional sources of income and revenue generation to be able to approve and pay for any fees going to the rent board or whatever it is, whatever the cost is going to be. Right now, it says $154. It's going to be higher. If the housing authority had to pay for that, what revenue do they have to you to to generate? They don't have it. … The only revenue they have that's not federally restricted is there is is primarily the rents that they receive. Some of those rents come from loans that the city gave to them. And the only way those loans get repaid is those rents are collected.”

    Context: Friedman argues the Housing Authority has no unrestricted revenue to pay registry or rent-board fees, and that those fees would come out of rents that repay city housing loans.

  • Eric FriedmanCouncilmemberSeptember 29, 2026Video · 3:55:26
    “Well, we received a letter today by the very same developers who are creating the housing that we all said we want, especially in that in downtown. The way it works is that lenders look at the market overall and the conditions in the market and if you have restrictions they look at what could it be 10 15 years from now the risk goes up so the cost to borrow money goes up … we need 1 to 2,000 units. We have a project that created 80 with a 10% affordable. And in this letter, he specifically says that if you pass this, the financing wouldn't work because it would cost more money to borrow.”

    Context: Friedman reads from a developers' letter received that day, arguing lenders price rent-regulation risk into financing even for new construction the ordinance does not cover.

  • Eric FriedmanCouncilmemberSeptember 29, 2026Video · 3:57:12
    “And again, this has been very expensive. I don't hear any conversations about how we're going to pay for this. It's already cost us close to half a million,400,000 [$400,000] in litigation. There's going to be more, especially if it doesn't pass. If it passes, we're probably going to have another attempt at a uh at a referendum. Those are all costs. Last week, we heard that when you have the the enforcement and the whole the whole program and all the fees, it only comes up to 80%. There's 20% that they just can't collect the fees for whatever reason, and it's not by lack of trying. So that would be subsidized by the general fund. Hundreds of thousands of dollars that I haven't heard anyway that's going to be paid for.”

    Context: Friedman tallies the program's costs: litigation to date, a likely referendum, and the 20% of fees staff expect not to collect, which the general fund would absorb.

  • Randy RowseMayorSeptember 29, 2026Video · 3:59:36
    “The community actually had a chance to vote on Prop 33 the last time it came through, which would have made Costa Hawkins a lot weaker and a lot easier to do this kind of thing. the community in Santa Barbara voted no. Now, we can poll, we can listen, we can do all these things, but the but that's the real the definitive poll is the ballot box. So, and we also talked about increased litigation exposure from this rent freeze going forward if we get to the first of the year. This is a selfinflicted [self-inflicted] exposure. This isn't like the bad boys from the outside doing this. We're doing this to ourselves.”

    Context: Rowse answers the claim that the community has long wanted rent control by pointing to the local Prop 33 vote, and calls the moratorium's litigation exposure self-inflicted.

  • Randy RowseMayorSeptember 29, 2026Video · 4:02:37
    “It's like saying to the city, okay, here's the deal. You want to do three uh 60% of CPI or plus 3% or whatever it is. Let's do that with, you know, water. Let's do that with electricity. Let's do all your employment contracts at those caps. Let's let's go for that. And you go, we can't do that. Well, what the hell's a landlord supposed to do who's in business for himself or herself? The same thing. They can't do that. They can't do it in perpetuity. Socializing a private asset is not the answer to happiness. It's the answer to a more limited supply.”

    Context: Rowse's closing argument against the cap: the city would never accept 60% of CPI or 3% on its own water, electricity or labor costs, and a capped private asset shrinks supply.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberSeptember 29, 2026Video · 4:06:44
    “Now, what I have seen in my research from other cities, the costs of the program are mostly covered. And usually what isn't covered is actually the fee that you are subsidizing or forgiving for the deed restricted affordable housing units. That is what we're going to have to find money to pay for if we don't charge the registry fee to them. And I'm okay with excluding them from the registry fee as long as we can find a way to pay for it. But I also don't want to promise anyone anything unless we have the fee study in front of us. … we unfortunately don't have the numbers for this city here and I so wish we did. That does make me feel a little bit of a hold up because it I want to make sure that what we're passing is is something that we can't afford.”

    Context: Responding to Friedman on cost, Santamaria says fee-funded programs elsewhere mostly cover themselves except for fees forgiven on deed-restricted units, and admits the city lacks its own numbers.

  • Dan HentschkeAssistant City AttorneySeptember 29, 2026Video · 4:17:15
    “I want to say that in terms of the exemption, the way that the exemption is is currently written, it is exempt from the entirety of chapter 26.90. All of it. … Habitability is already addressed in the ordinance because you um for rent controlled units because you can't get a rent increase without that. But there is nothing in chapter 26 90 [26.90] that is an enforcement mechanism with regard to habitability. … the rent board is as we told you at the last meeting is a hearing on a hearing body that considers whether it considers appeals of a decision on a rent petition. … It is it is not a um an enforcement agency and never has been. That's not how it's ever been written.”

    Context: Asked whether exempt tenants could still reach the rent board over habitability, Hentschke explains that the exemption covers all of Chapter 26.90 and that the board is not an enforcement body.

  • John DoimasCity AttorneySeptember 29, 2026Video · 4:20:32
    “the issue is what are we passing tonight? And that's where we need clarity because is the structure to pass what is before you the RS the RSO as it's written currently before you today. And why that's important too is because the next step of course is to bring it back for adoption. So we need that clarity. So if we know that there isn't anything else being added to it that we are coming back right away now with the adoption and that process of 30 days and … everything else will follow suit.”

    Context: Doimas interrupts the habitability exchange to pin down what the council is voting on, warning that any addition to the text would restart the adoption clock.

  • Barbara AndersenSenior Assistant to the City AdministratorSeptember 29, 2026Video · 4:22:24
    “Completeness includes notifying the landlord of habitability issues and offering the opportunity for corrective action which we would do with a housing authority property dealing directly with the housing authority and that property owner. That habitability inspection is code enforcement that remains in and outside of the rent stabilization ordinance. That process does not change. The only change is that there could be a downward adjustment in rent that an administrative hearing officer would issue findings on, not the rent stabilization board. If the tenant disagrees or the property owner disagrees, they can appeal to the board to then consider that. … the adjustments that the housing authority can make to actually completely relinquish federal assistance payments to that property owner in absence of habitability being addressed is actually a more powerful tool than we will have with the rent stabilization ordinance as it's drafted.”

    Context: Answering Santamaria's question about what the exemption removes, Andersen walks through the tenant-petition process. The captions do not name the speaker; the attribution rests on content and her habitual address.

  • Dan HentschkeAssistant City AttorneySeptember 29, 2026Video · 4:23:33
    “Yeah, that is correct. And I would like to point out you you mentioned San Francisco. The San Francisco does exempt section 8 from its rent control provisions. It does not exempt section 8 from just cause exactly like we currently do it in Santa Barb in Santa Barbara.”

    Context: Confirming that remodel-related habitability belongs in Just Cause, Hentschke corrects Santamaria's San Francisco example: that city exempts Section 8 from rent control but not from just cause.

  • Dan HentschkeAssistant City AttorneySeptember 29, 2026Video · 4:26:18
    “if we do need to make subsequent adjustments to the rent stabilization, we can do that by a subsequent ordinance when we have more information on whether or not it adequately addresses the habitability concerns. And and frankly, I think that there's a significant legal issue that we have to evaluate about a tenant petition as it intersects with section 8. I don't know that we can do that in a short period of time. Really need to evaluate how those regulations intersect particularly um with respect to the federal regulations. And so the so we we think we have lots of tenant protections for habitability existing.”

    Context: Hentschke tells the council a habitability petition for Section 8 tenants raises a federal-law question staff cannot resolve quickly, and that any change would come by later ordinance.

  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberSeptember 29, 2026Video · 4:31:36
    “I will move adoption of the ordinance ordinance pursuant to staff recommendation and direct our staff to explore opportunities to improve habitability, including through the just cause ordinance and other mechanisms as they see fit.”

    Context: At the Clerk's request Harmon restates the motion that passed 4–3 moments later: introduce the ordinance per staff recommendation, with direction to staff on habitability.

  • Barbara AndersenSenior Assistant to the City AdministratorSeptember 22, 2026Video · 1:24:02
    “at full implementation staff is anticipating 7 to nine full-time equivalent positions and total annual budget expenditures of $2 to $2.4 $4 million. That is based on the ordinance as introduced and on the experience of comparable California jurisdictions. … First, the earlier estimate estimate presented to council will rise. The $2 million total and the $154 per unit figure predate council's direction to extend the registry citywide and to narrow the exemptions along with incorporating the cost for petitions.”

    Context: Presenting the introduction draft, Andersen updates the program's cost: the $2 million / $154-per-unit estimate that has anchored the debate since May is obsolete.

  • Barbara AndersenSenior Assistant to the City AdministratorSeptember 22, 2026Video · 1:25:01
    “Third, fees cover most, not all. The two-tier struct fee two-tier fee structure, excuse me, is expected to cover most annual operating costs, but full cost recovery is not anticipated in the early years, if at all. It's important for us to highlight that no program in the state of California has reached full cost recovery. So, staff is recommending that measure I bridges that gap um by a declining amount as the program matures and stabilizes.”

    Context: Closing the cost section of the staff presentation, Andersen explains why the registry fee will not fund the program on its own.

  • Kristen SneddonCouncilmember (Mayor Pro Tem)September 22, 2026Video · 2:48:09
    “I will admit that's less straightforward than I thought it was. I thought it was a calcul so an economist has to be involved. … that's more complicated than I thought it was.”

    Context: After Hentschke explains that a fair-return petition turns on a rebuttable MNOI presumption and economist testimony rather than a lookup formula, the ordinance's co-author reacts.

  • Barbara AndersenSenior Assistant to the City AdministratorSeptember 22, 2026Video · 2:55:30
    “Um RSG calculated for us is about $27,000 from program staff time, technical consultation, the hearing officer time, and additional legal support for the fair return petition process. And the capital improvement petition process is approximately $13,950.”

    Context: Answering Friedman's question about what a petition actually costs to process, Andersen cites RSG's per-petition estimates — costs the July 28 direction folds into the registry fee.

  • Eric FriedmanCouncilmemberSeptember 22, 2026Video · 3:08:51
    “we're we're basically being asked tonight uh my colleagues up here is to adopt a program that either meets the revenue generation and so has a lower level of service which is going to create a lot of issues. um or we adopt a program that meets the expectations but then there's going to be a large general fund subsidy because of that 80%. So the two choices before us.”

    Context: Having established with staff that 80% fee compliance on a $2.4 million budget leaves about half a million dollars a year to the general fund, Friedman frames the decision.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberSeptember 22, 2026Video · 3:46:00
    “I'm curious about what it would look like if we brought back the fee study before we adopt the ordinance. … I've heard from both property owners and tenants, you know, everybody wants to know how much it's going to cost them before we adopt the ordinance.”

    Context: Near the end of council questions, the ordinance's lead sponsor asks whether adoption could wait for the fee study.

  • Kelly McAdooCity AdministratorSeptember 22, 2026Video · 3:47:01
    “there is absolutely no way we would implement by Jul January 1st if we wait till after the fee study comes back.”

    Context: Responding to Santamaria's suggestion to bring the fee study back before adoption, McAdoo states the trade-off between knowing the cost and keeping the launch date.

  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberSeptember 22, 2026Video · 4:24:41
    “Uh the exemption for deed restricted affordable units and the exemption for housing choice voucher tendencies [tenancies] are critical to my support for this ordinance. Um to me, those two exemptions are a red line.”

    Context: Opening deliberations after the recess, Harmon states the condition of her vote.

  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberSeptember 22, 2026Video · 4:25:56
    “That said, I do continue to have um sort of a fundamental overarching concern here that we are separating the drafting of this ordinance from the development of our understanding of how it's going to be implemented. Truthfully, that bifurcation does undermine my confidence in my own understanding of what I'm voting for.”

    Context: Harmon, who will vote yes, explains the reservation she carries into the vote.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberSeptember 22, 2026Video · 4:39:18
    “it is really difficult for any one of us no matter how much we are champions of this ordinance to go to someone and say actually I don't know how much you're going to pay for this I used to be able to tell people right it was 154 that we estimated and so that unknown wasn't really an unknown. We at least had an estimate. And now that we don't have an estimate as to how much it's going to be per unit, per year is it's a it's a harder cell [sell]. It just is.”

    Context: In deliberation, the lead sponsor describes the effect of staff's cost update on her ability to explain the program to constituents.

  • Kelly McAdooCity AdministratorSeptember 22, 2026Video · 4:42:13
    “I think to be clear, we need clear direction. Like if we can't just do the fee study without having clear direction on what's exempted, what you want included. So we need to have that direction from count[cil] and every time we come it has changed and I I and we have added more things. So this we can't just come back and start doing a fee study like we need direction from council.”

    Context: Interrupting Santamaria's suggestion to pair adoption with the fee study, McAdoo explains why the study has not started.

  • Dan HentschkeAssistant City AttorneySeptember 22, 2026Video · 4:46:32
    “There is no case law that says that it is um preempted. There's no case law says that it is not preempted. There is a risk if you include it. If you want to exclude it, we only included it because we thought the council wanted the broadest possible coverage.”

    Context: Asked by Santamaria whether covering corporate-owned single-family homes conflicts with Costa-Hawkins, Hentschke describes the legal exposure of a provision present since the June 10 draft.

  • Kristen SneddonCouncilmember (Mayor Pro Tem)September 22, 2026Video · 4:50:30
    “And so I'm know I'm going to take a lot of heat for this, but I I think going at a 3% cap that makes it just so that for the first year we are not dealing with fair rate petition calculations and complications and understanding that this is an iterative uh process that a rent board will weigh in on. will have data, rental registry, um that I'd be okay with that, too.”

    Context: During deliberation, the ordinance's co-sponsor suggests a flat 3% cap for the first year in place of 60% of CPI, citing the complexity of fair-return petitions she had just learned about.

  • Kristen SneddonCouncilmember (Mayor Pro Tem)September 22, 2026Video · 4:55:54
    “what I understood from tonight's meeting is how much far more complicated that is and expensive than I had previously understood. I thought it was a formula. You enter the numbers into the formula and that's how it was a little bit presented before. So tonight is sort of a a very different understanding for me than anything as I've understood it up until now.”

    Context: Clarifying her 3% suggestion for Harmon and counsel, Sneddon explains what changed her view.

  • Mike JordanCouncilmemberSeptember 22, 2026Video · 5:06:33
    “most importantly, I mean, you can Google this yourself, a freeze with no ROI um process has a shelf life, and we're at the end of that shelf life. You now have landlords out there who are going on the almost two years without any rent increase option at all.”

    Context: Explaining why he seconded Harmon's motion to force a vote he would oppose, Jordan warns that the moratorium's legal footing is running out.

  • Randy RowseMayorSeptember 22, 2026Video · 5:10:50
    “Was there a financial model that justifies 60% versus 3%. or was it just what we could legally get away with … going forward with this ordinance without even knowing what the base costs are for sure without this fee study isn't something that is good practice to begin with … this is not a very proud moment for this council.”

    Context: Closing deliberation before the votes, Rowse reacts to the last-minute 3% suggestion and the missing fee study.

  • Kelly McAdooCity AdministratorSeptember 22, 2026Video · 5:23:19
    “the clarification is you're actually not introducing the ordinance tonight. You this is this is you're directing us to come back to reintroduce the ordinance next week in the form that it is that that gets landed on tonight. So I think you're giving direction for the final draft of the ordinance.”

    Context: Answering Friedman's question whether splitting the votes amounts to a reconsideration, McAdoo clarifies the legal status of the evening's votes.

  • Barbara AndersenSenior Assistant to the City AdministratorJuly 28, 2026Video · 4:08:34
    “The community has been heard. We are not debating for or against rent stabilization. Community direction is clear. Council direction is clear. This is moving forward. And now we are working to refine the ordinance to create a program that can hopefully meet expectations and objectives.”

    Context: Opening the July 28 hearing on the public-comment summary and final ordinance amendments, Andersen frames the meeting's premise: the for-or-against debate is over.

  • Barbara AndersenSenior Assistant to the City AdministratorJuly 28, 2026Video · 4:14:17
    “we are currently seeking cost proposals for a third party fee study. We are estimating these costs to be between $35 and $50,000 and that includes a 12-week timeline to complete that study.”

    Context: Explaining that the program's fee structure will be set later by separate resolution, Andersen discloses the city is only now soliciting a third-party fee study.

  • Barbara AndersenSenior Assistant to the City AdministratorJuly 28, 2026Video · 4:15:45
    “requiring every unit to register may push some owners of unpermitted or non-conforming units such as unpermitted ADUs or garage conversions to end a ten[anc]y rather than register and expose themselves to code enforcement. In other words, a registry meant to protect tenants could for a narrow set of units put those same tenants at risk of dis displacement.”

    Context: Presenting the open question of whether the rental registry must cover all units, Andersen relays staff's warning about unpermitted units.

  • Randy RowseMayorJuly 28, 2026Video · 5:49:48
    “staff has gone to incredible length and a lot of efforts to do this and put this together. And some of the comments made tonight, some of the invective, some of the negativity about motivations or competence are really out of place and unfortunate and shouldn't be happening here. Staff is working their butt off to do this. … being a bully is not the way to get things done.”

    Context: Before deliberation begins, Rowse rebukes the tone of the evening's public comment toward city staff.

  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberJuly 28, 2026Video · 6:02:54
    “for what amounts to essentially very little additional price protection, we meaningfully increase the risk that one ongoing source of funding to build that capital Affordable housing, the exact kind of housing that we need and want[,] dries up.”

    Context: Harmon — alone on the council — argues for exempting deed-restricted affordable housing, warning the RSO could choke off the residual-receipts loan repayments that fund new affordable units.

  • Eric FriedmanCouncilmemberJuly 28, 2026Video · 6:04:58
    “With that being said, uh the majority, you're going to do what you're going to do and uh you have a lot of people behind you. There's a lot of people that don't support it, but and that's the way that's the way elections work and I'm fine with that.”

    Context: Friedman, in the minority, explains he largely stopped engaging after the April 7 cap vote landed at 60% of CPI despite signals the number could move.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberJuly 28, 2026Video · 6:13:12
    “I really want to for us to narrow the scope of the exemptions because every exemption for one type of provider is leaving hundreds of tenants unprotected. And so I don't want to leave in higher ed. I don't want to leave higher ed staff or students unprotected.”

    Context: Arguing against exemptions for higher-education and Section 8 housing, Santamaria states her blanket principle on coverage.

  • Dan HentschkeAssistant City AttorneyJuly 28, 2026Video · 6:36:18
    “We do not want to present to you an ordinance … recommended for adoption that we think won't withstand constitutional scrutiny.”

    Context: After council direction on capital-improvement pass-through limits, Hentschke cautions that several amendments need constitutional vetting before the final draft returns.

  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberJuly 28, 2026Video · 7:01:44
    “Practically speaking, one of the things that has been weighing on me very heavily is there's the drafting of the ordinance, which I'm so glad that we're we're so focused on the the smallest words. That's really great. And there's this huge cavernous gulf between what we're talking about and how we're actually going to implement this program. And I have no idea how we're going to do that. And I to me that is where I'm what keeps me up at night is how we actually do this.”

    Context: Responding to staff's question about phasing the all-units rental registry, Harmon voices her core worry about the program.

  • Dan HentschkeAssistant City AttorneyJuly 28, 2026Video · 8:16:44
    “What I want to advise is precluding a a landlord from obtaining a capital pass through because of their corporate status is going to put you smack dab into a constitutional argument.”

    Context: As council pushes to deny capital-improvement pass-throughs to corporate and large owners, Hentschke warns the line cannot be drawn by owner identity.

  • Randy RowseMayorJune 9, 2026Video · 4:07:48
    “What are we spending a whole bunch of money on? The RSO… Not only have we spent a bunch of money on it so far, the projected amount of money we're going to spend is monster. I'm not in favor of the program and we're already in a lawsuit that we've had to do because of the rent freeze when we've had to allocate $400,000.”

    Context: During the earlier FY budget discussion, Rowse cites the rent stabilization program's projected costs and the $400,000 rent-freeze lawsuit as a major expense, stating his opposition.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberJune 9, 2026Video · 7:11:55
    “this is a really exciting opportunity for us to provide protections that did not exist before and to preserve the stability and the integrity of this community. And so I I want to take us out of any if anybody is in the mentality of like fear, oh lawsuits, oh money, like you know, we're we are truly doing a community benefit that has been in progress for decades.”

    Context: Santamaria's framing opening remarks, explicitly dismissing concerns about litigation and cost as 'fear' before launching her amendment requests.

  • Dan HentschkeAssistant City AttorneyJune 9, 2026Video · 7:16:07
    “generally when you have a rent board that has more regulatory authority, it's a a much more um expensive program to administer and it was we believed the direction of the council to have a rent board that was primarily adjudicatory and advisory in its capacity.”

    Context: Responding to Santamaria's push for a regulatory rent board, Hentschke warns that a more powerful board materially raises administration costs.

  • Dan HentschkeAssistant City AttorneyJune 9, 2026Video · 7:20:17
    “the presumption is that whatever the landlord was charging at on the base rent was a fair return at the time because there was no restriction on that rent. So that was market rent at the time and whatever net operating income they were receiving from the operation that was a fair return to them. So that that's the assumption that underlies that approach.”

    Context: Hentschke explains the constitutional fair-return mechanism: the maintenance-of-net-operating-income standard presumes the 2025 base-year NOI was already a fair return.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberJune 9, 2026Video · 7:25:02
    “I think this is going to cause some issues where property owners are essentially double dipping because then you can raise your rents on which what we allow the base rent and 6% CPI up to 3%. then you can come in and do capital improvements and submit a different petition to start passing on the cost for one another one project and then a different project.”

    Context: Santamaria argues the separate capital-improvement pass-through petition lets owners 'double dip' and should be folded into the fair-return petition.

  • Barbara AndersenSenior Assistant to the City AdministratorJune 9, 2026Video · 7:26:12
    “this is a key area where RSG was advising us based on other rent stabilization programs to actually separate it out. Um, given the rent cap formula adjustment being 60% of CPI and and no exceptions for small property owners, the capital improvement petition process is their pathway to recoup some of those cost when they don't they're not operating, you know, multiple units and multiple properties across the city.”

    Context: Staff, relying on RSG consultant advice, defends keeping a separate capital petition as the principal cost-recovery path for small landlords under a 60%-of-CPI cap with no small-owner exemption.

  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberJune 9, 2026Video · 8:11:56
    “I'm a little bit confused on the insistence on not exempting deed restricted housing. These units are already price controlled and in a lot of ways deed restricted housing are the only units that actually have vacancy control… coupled with the fact that there's constitutional issues such that the other jurisdictions don't even enforce the rent control ordinances on deed restricted units. I we're like fighting over something that just doesn't I don't understand it and it seems to add a lot of complexity for our affordable housing providers who are just trying so hard to survive”

    Context: Harmon breaks with Santamaria, arguing the push to regulate already-covenanted deed-restricted units adds complexity for affordable-housing providers with no real benefit.

  • Eric FriedmanCouncilmemberJune 9, 2026Video · 8:14:07
    “regarding the section 8 and not exempting it, I still think that's very misguided… [reading Rob Pearson] you are assured with section 8 that the tenant is only paying 30% of their income as rent. It's an easy win all around and I see no downside. It will also promote administrative ease for all tenants, landlords, city staff, and housing authority staff by not having to juggle two payment limits. Further, HUD annually sets the fair market rents for the section 8 program, and it historically lags actual market rents.”

    Context: Friedman, opposed to the program, reads former 35-year Housing Authority director Rob Pearson's email urging explicit Section 8 and deed-restricted exemptions.

  • Sarah CourtRSG consultantMay 19, 2026Video · 3:07:23
    “using an estimated cost of approximately $154 per covered unit and an estimated 13,000 covered units in the city. Um that equates to an estimated program cost of approximately $2 million annually. Um, so it's important to note here that actual program costs may vary depending on the final ordinance structure and the level of administrative … services and oversight needed to carry out the ordinance as directed by city council.”

    Context: RSG presenting its preliminary estimate of the annual cost to administer the rent stabilization program.

  • Sarah CourtRSG consultantMay 19, 2026Video · 3:32:02
    “Four of the five peer jurisdictions review use formulas ranging from approximately 70% to 100% of CPI generally paired with fixed caps between three and 5%. Research and peer jurisdiction experience suggests that lower rent caps may in some cases increase reliance on the petition process where landlords believe allowable increases do not keep pace with operating costs or provide a reasonable return.”

    Context: RSG summarizing peer rent-cap formulas and the feasibility risks of setting a cap below market peers in response to council's request to study lower caps.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberMay 19, 2026Video · 4:32:57
    “comparing the mobile home park rent ordinance to the one that we're crafting right now is truly apples to oranges. They do not have vacancy decontrol. We do and there is a reason why they have a higher rent cap because they cannot adjust all the way to market rates the way that all of the units that would be covered under the rent stabilization ordinance would.”

    Context: Santamaria's central rationale for rejecting the staff-suggested 75% CPI mobile-home cap and keeping the lower 60% CPI cap, hinging on the presence of vacancy decontrol in the new ordinance.

  • Barbara AndersenSenior Assistant to the City AdministratorMay 19, 2026Video · 4:51:02
    “we tend to see the longer standing ordinances Santa Monica, Berkeley, um those that have been around for a long time have significantly built out processes um for both tenants and landlords um to offer services. They have staff around 22 to 25 um specific to the rent stabilization program.”

    Context: Staff explaining to Mayor Rowse why Santa Monica spends ~$6M/yr (three times Santa Barbara's ~$2M estimate) on its rent program.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberMay 19, 2026Video · 5:03:51
    “for the rent cap formula, I am going through and seeing our 40 plus year old mobile home rent cap ordinance. It is not like our rent stabilization ordinance that we are crafting today. … They need a higher rent cap because they cannot bring their units or their lots up to market rate. … I would encourage option B. … I don't see necessarily new data for changing the rent cap formula.”

    Context: Santamaria's formal comment urging no change to the 60% CPI / 3% cap, calling it and the Section 8 exemption the issues she feels strongest about because 'there are real people on the literal chopping block.'

  • Kristen SneddonCouncilmember (Mayor Pro Tem)May 19, 2026Video · 5:08:56
    “when I first read this, I thought, oh, it's 75% for the mobile home park and that's a similar thing. But then realizing that the mobile home park ordinance is rent control. It isn't vacancy decontrol. So it it creates that sort of false equivalence that these are addressing the same issue. So, um, on that one, I would just keep moving forward as we've been doing.”

    Context: Sneddon endorsing maintaining the existing rent-cap direction, framing the mobile-home 75% cap as a 'false equivalence' because it is hard rent control without vacancy decontrol.

  • Randy RowseMayorMay 19, 2026Video · 5:11:03
    “I think it's a train wreck both for landlords and tenants in the long run. … by looking at the details in the report we saw today, if we carry these out, I think we're very much underestimating the costs of carrying this out. … We haven't done a f we've got a financial analysis of what it is from one side, but not from the other. … we've pretty much put a very chilled atmosphere out there in the business of being a landlord.”

    Context: Mayor Rowse's lone-dissent closing comment opposing the direction, asserting the program costs are underestimated and that the fiscal analysis examined only one side.

  • Barbara AndersenSenior Assistant to the City AdministratorMay 19, 2026Video · 5:12:26
    “in terms of the examples, 60% of the change of CPI is not the majority of rent stabilization programs throughout California or the nation. So, I think there was a reference that it was and it was best practice and it's and that's not the case from the research nor the research presented in the staff report.”

    Context: Staff's closing correction of the record, rebutting the suggestion that a 60% CPI cap is the majority approach or 'best practice.'

  • Natalyia GluskBudget Manager (Finance)May 12, 2026Video · 3:38:45
    “There's also startup costs for um implementation of the rent stabilization program.… There's also a fee study that we will be conducting to support the rent stabilizations program and measure I is supporting um the rent stabilization program as well.”

    Context: In the staff budget presentation, Glusk identifies startup costs, a supporting fee study, and Measure I funding tied to the rent stabilization program.

  • Eric FriedmanCouncilmemberMay 12, 2026Video · 4:25:45
    “does that also include the item from today on the 300,000 that we transferred out um for the litigation?”

    Context: Friedman probes whether the displayed Flexible Housing Fund figures already account for the litigation transfer approved that day.

  • Natalyia GluskBudget Manager (Finance)May 12, 2026Video · 4:26:30
    “1 million for uh the operations of [Casa Esperanza]. Uh and then uh $400,000 that the council just approved uh for uh for attorney services to defend the rent stabilization ordinance.”

    Context: Answering Friedman on FY27 Flexible Housing Fund uses, Glusk confirms $400,000 going to legal defense of the rent stabilization ordinance.

  • Kristen SneddonCouncilmember (Mayor Pro Tem)May 12, 2026Video · 4:35:56
    “there is a h 100,000 remaining which I mean is usable money towards um rental stabilization ordinance or to other things.”

    Context: Sneddon, reconciling the Flexible Housing Fund line items, identifies roughly $100,000 unallocated that could be applied to the rent stabilization ordinance.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberMay 12, 2026Video · 4:58:52
    “essentially all of the money that we are considering allocating in fiscal year 27 is already spoken for and we have a rent stabilization ordinance that is coming before us. It's going to happen and we need… funding for the startup costs. The program and the fees that we will collect… will eventually kick in and we'll be able to sustain the program, but in the beginning we're going to need startup money.”

    Context: Santamaria warns during the mid-cycle budget discussion that FY27 funds are largely committed while the forthcoming rent stabilization program needs startup money before its fees can sustain it.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberMay 12, 2026Video · 4:59:40
    “if we are not providing the adequate funding to get this program properly off the ground and to function the way it's intended, we're only going to create more costs for the city. So, I very much want to highlight that we need to do some serious work on identifying startup money for the rent stabilization ordinance”

    Context: Santamaria argues that underfunding the program at launch will generate larger downstream costs for the City.

  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberMay 5, 2026Video · 4:09:30
    “the elephant in the room for me when it comes to policy is our council's commitment to moving forward with the rent stabilization program I believe strongly that that program is a good thing. But or maybe and the research says that the degree to which rent stabilization is effective at stabilizing communities over time is in direct relation to our ability to incentivize, lower the cost of, and expedite housing production at the same time.”

    Context: Harmon opens her in-lieu fee deliberation by tying her position to the council's in-progress rent stabilization program and conditioning that program's effectiveness on housing production.

  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberMay 5, 2026Video · 4:09:30
    “It's that second leg of the three-legged stool of ameliorating our housing crisis. … Rent stabilization is one leg. Housing production and incentivizing it is another.”

    Context: Harmon characterizes rent stabilization as one of three interdependent 'legs' (the others being housing production/incentives) in the council's housing-crisis strategy.

  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberMay 5, 2026Video · 4:10:55
    “setting fees at the highest legally defensible amount simply doesn't reflect the kind of pro-[housing] policies we need to implement to make our stabilization program work now while at the same time building towards solving the crisis in the long term.”

    Context: Harmon argues against maximizing in-lieu fees, framing lower fees as necessary to make the rent stabilization program work by supporting housing production.

  • Kelly McAdooCity AdministratorApril 28, 2026Video · 0:36:05
    “we are proposing to use some of the unallocated balance in the basically the funds from measure I sales tax that have gone into the flexible housing fund to cover the litigation costs as this is related to uh the rent stabilization program development and and rent moratorium. So that … money would then go back to replenish the reserves consistent with policy.”

    Context: McAdoo explains the funding source: reserves backfilled from the Measure I flexible housing fund, tying the litigation cost directly to the rent stabilization program and moratorium.

  • Eric FriedmanCouncilmemberApril 28, 2026Video · 0:38:12
    “So um I won't be supporting this. … we are currently in our emergency reserves in the city and uh, we haven't even had an emergency yet. And so we're scrambling to try to find ways and now it appears we're going to be perhaps reducing some of the services that we would be able to provide through our flexible housing fund. And this lawsuit uh, was avoidable 100%. It could have been done a different way that would have avoided litigation.”

    Context: Friedman explains his no vote on funding the rent-stabilization litigation defense, calling the lawsuit avoidable and warning it drains emergency reserves and the flexible housing fund.

  • John DoimasCity AttorneyApril 28, 2026Video · 0:41:26
    “I can say this pretty fairly conf if we have to go all the way with the litigation and then lose and battle that it would most likely be more than $400,000.”

    Context: Doimas confirms to Jordan that the $400,000 is only an estimate and that a full trial loss, with adversary attorney-fee exposure, would likely exceed it.

  • Mike JordanCouncilmemberApril 28, 2026Video · 0:42:14
    “if you do a back of a napkin math on the reserves, where we are now and where we should be, it's probably something like, uh, $3 million a year for 15 years just to get back to where we should be. … it's not really … about where it comes from. It's just about continuing to dig a hole um in our available dollars for anything. And um for that reason … I won't won't support this either.”

    Context: Jordan opposes the appropriation, framing the litigation cost as compounding an already severe reserve shortfall.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberApril 28, 2026Video · 0:45:12
    “the same corporate landlord lobby who couldn't afford relocation assistance and can't afford to put off a single rent increase somehow has the money to sue us. … it is my belief that we need to equip our city attorney's office with the tools that they need to defend us.”

    Context: Santamaria's rationale for supporting the litigation funding, characterizing the plaintiffs as a corporate-landlord lobby.

  • Kristen SneddonCouncilmember (Mayor Pro Tem)April 28, 2026Video · 0:46:47
    “why aren't we hearing this in closed session? It is clear that this is turning into a political discussion and we can't speak freely. … even by the comments about whether this was preventable or meritless … is um reference to discussions within close session and I don't think that's appropriate.”

    Context: Sneddon objects that the litigation-funding item is becoming a political debate touching closed-session strategy, the concern that ultimately drives the continuance.

  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberApril 28, 2026Video · 0:52:58
    “I will support um this item when it comes back before us. … these are incredibly complex areas of law and policy that we are wading into. And I think that it is vitally important that we see these questions through um to their end. And that means investing in the conversation whether we're talking about it from a policy perspective or uh through the legal lens.”

    Context: Harmon confirms a brief delay causes no litigation harm and signals she will support the appropriation when it returns.

  • Randy RowseMayorApril 28, 2026Video · 0:53:58
    “this is one of these things that is uh was we put ourselves in this position was self-inflicted … I agree with Mr. Jordan and Mr. [Friedman] and not support but I'm going to support the motion because we're stuck in this situation. We're going to need to have this authority to go forward and uh I don't see any reason to continue this.”

    Context: Rowse calls the litigation a self-inflicted predicament but says the city is now stuck needing the funding authority, and opposes continuing the item.

  • Keith MartiniFinance Director (budget presenter)April 21, 2026Video · 2:13:21
    “There are a couple things that that come to mind, not in no particular order. One would be uh the potential litigation or the potential operating cost of the city for the rent stabilization ordinance.”

    Context: Answering Councilmember Friedman's question about budget unknowns not accounted for in the general-fund reserves.

  • Eric FriedmanCouncilmemberApril 21, 2026Video · 2:13:21
    “are there any unknowns in terms of um expenditures uh that could that are not cooked into the budget or any potential revenues that are in there that could either exacerbate and go us further uh dip further into the emergency reserves or build them that are not accounted for in any of the of the budget.”

    Context: Friedman's question prompting staff to name the rent stabilization ordinance as an un-budgeted fiscal risk.

  • Keith MartiniFinance Director (budget presenter)April 21, 2026Video · 2:14:07
    “So, we know that there's active litigation. So, to pay for that, as well as a potential cost of implementing a program if council were to approve that, um there would be a fee component to that program, I believe, but I it most certainly probably would not be fully cost recoverable.”

    Context: Staff explaining that an eventual rent stabilization program would carry administrative costs only partly offset by program fees.

  • Keith MartiniFinance Director (budget presenter)April 21, 2026Video · 2:14:07
    “Neither of those programs are approved by council at this time. So, it is not appropriate to budget for the financial impact of those ordinances”

    Context: Staff's rationale for excluding rent-stabilization costs from the FY2027 budget — the ordinance is not yet council-approved.

  • Sarah Court / Tara BrottenRSG consultants (staff presentation)April 7, 2026Video · 3:18:23
    “generally if … you have a very low rent cap, it could cause for … more petitions for fair returns from housing providers.”

    Context: RSG consultant flags, during the rent-limits presentation, the fiscal/administrative trade-off that low caps drive more fair-return petitions.

  • Sarah Court / Tara BrottenRSG consultants (staff presentation)April 7, 2026Video · 3:39:48
    “you're framing your percentage off of CPI on a frame that doesn't take into account what could or couldn't be … escalating costs of a particular category that is often times unique to a property owner and not to the general public.”

    Context: Jordan presses the RSG consultants on why CPI (a consumer index) is used as the cap basis when landlord cost categories like commercial insurance and water rates diverge from CPI.

  • Sarah Court / Tara BrottenRSG consultants (staff presentation)April 7, 2026Video · 3:50:13
    “Now the fun part which keeps all the attorneys really busy is that there's no actual legal definition of fair return. … the one most recognized way … is a maintenance of net operating income or NOI approach which … looks at … the income and expenses of … rental property and making sure that they're being able to maintain like a level of profit over time and they're constitutionally … entitled to that.”

    Context: RSG defines 'fair return' for the Mayor, explaining the NOI-maintenance standard and that denying it is a regulatory taking.

  • Kristen SneddonCouncilmemberApril 7, 2026Video · 6:32:40
    “I knew that the 60% was the lowest number that was legally defensible from the research and … fully expected that that number would be negotiated upward … but something had to go in there as a placeholder.”

    Context: Sneddon explains, responding to Friedman, that the 60% figure in the earlier sample ordinance was a placeholder she expected to be negotiated higher.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberApril 7, 2026Video · 6:35:45
    “And the reason for 60% of CPI is that CPI in itself 40% of that is already housing. And so we don't want to count housing twice. And that is what we would be doing if we put it at 100% of CPI. … We talk a lot about the Santa Barbara way and it needs to be tailored more to our living expenses.”

    Context: Santamaria states her rationale while making the formal motion to set the rent cap at 60% of CPI.

  • Randy RowseMayorApril 7, 2026Video · 6:40:35
    “I won't be supporting the motion only because with 1482, what we learned was landlords felt compelled to go to the whatever the floor was or what the cap was … immediately to protect themselves. And that's how we ended up with that … hyperinflationary rent even from landlords that didn't raise every year.”

    Context: Rowse explains his 'no' vote on the 60% CPI / 3% cap, arguing caps induce landlords to take the maximum every year.

  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberApril 7, 2026Video · 6:40:35
    “I feel a little bit like I'm … making a decision in the void to be frank around numbers and it feels a little bit like guesswork which I'm struggling with. … I would love if possible to see a chart for maybe the last 10 years that would identify specifically what CPI would have been in each of the last 10 years and to benchmark what 60% 75% and 100% would have been.”

    Context: Harmon, while supporting the motion, concedes the council is voting on the cap number without seeing the underlying CPI data and requests a historical chart.

  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberApril 7, 2026Video · 6:52:01
    “One of the areas for me is around vacancy deontrol [decontrol] specifically. … the minute that we move out, I have real concern that rent prices are going to shoot up. … They're likely to look at … all families with school-aged children … and say you're probably going to be here for 10 years. you're no longer the kind of tenant that we want to rent to.”

    Context: Harmon raises an 'intellectually honest' concern that vacancy decontrol plus long-tenancy incentives could lead landlords to screen out families and seniors.

  • Barbara AndersenSenior Assistant to the City AdministratorMarch 17, 2026Video · 0:16:14
    “the original cost proposal was over $80,000. You see before you today a $65,000 agreement. Um it is specific to data collection and analysis as relates to total impacted units under a potential ordinance… they are assisting us with um looking at legal and administrative cost implications of implementing a rent stabilization program.”

    Context: Andersen describes the narrowed RSG scope and its core deliverables when Jordan questions why an outside consultant is needed.

  • Mike JordanCouncilmemberMarch 17, 2026Video · 0:19:37
    “my concern is just this is um potentially, I guess, at this time at least, the tip of the iceberg in a black hole of uh financial resources… without having people being able to make a decision based on the entire scope of the financial commitment even before we get to a successful rent stabilization ordinance.”

    Context: Jordan, who pulled the item, explains his refusal to commit funds without knowing the total financial scope of the program.

  • Barbara AndersenSenior Assistant to the City AdministratorMarch 17, 2026Video · 0:21:30
    “A lot of municipalities who've done this work have learned from the work, and I will say have absorbed increasing costs because of what they did not anticipate on the front end. So, ordinance adoption is one part of the process, but what you include in that ordinance impacts every single step of implementation, from the petition process to the appeals process… even the number of exemptions, if you have no exemptions outside of state law, that creates more petitions, which creates more staffing capacity needed.”

    Context: Andersen explains why technical consulting is needed, warning that ordinance design choices drive downstream administrative and staffing costs.

  • Barbara AndersenSenior Assistant to the City AdministratorMarch 17, 2026Video · 0:22:41
    “everything has a ripple effect, and I think having that level of expertise, I will say is not just a comfort place. It's necessary for us to do the work in a way that's as most cost efficient as possible for the City of Santa Barbara given our financial circumstances.”

    Context: Andersen answers Santamaria's question on why the consultant is a cost-effective approach despite the expense.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberMarch 17, 2026Video · 0:24:47
    “I am usually very apprehensive of consultants because it's it's always, right? It's just like this black hole of just like we just throw money… but also, I I really want to recognize that staff is doing everything possible to put as little work on that consultant. And if it's only technical support, then the way I'm seeing this is this is a way to support you all because this ordinance, you were already given direction by Council to complete this ordinance and develop this program.”

    Context: Santamaria explains her support for funding the consultant as backstop technical support for already-directed staff work.

  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberMarch 17, 2026Video · 0:26:21
    “We could have done it for free, but we wouldn't have done it well, um and there would have been a lot of questions that we didn't think to even ask and a lot of information that we didn't have… I don't love spending money now, either, but this is um money that's imperative, I believe, that we spend.”

    Context: Harmon supports the spend, framing it as inherent to doing the ordinance thoroughly rather than quickly.

  • Randy RowseMayorMarch 17, 2026Video · 0:27:40
    “I will not be supporting this. The the timeline and compression is self-imposed by our freeze… I don't think this is a adequate kind of money that you're going to need to get the kind of information to craft something that, you know, I oppose anyway, but I don't know that it would even work. It's almost impossible to to glean that kind of information out of the community, the mixture of housing we have and whatnot.”

    Context: Rowse states his opposition, tying the rushed timeline to the rent freeze and doubting the data can even be gathered.

  • Mike JordanCouncilmemberJanuary 27, 2026Video · 0:32:48
    “staff didn't really have anything to hand out. We were pushed towards going to the resources that the rental housing … mediation task force offers, which is not anything that's required by either party, so it didn't really apply when somebody's getting illegal notices and forced out of an apartment … by eviction notices and construction. … your problem as an individual is not our problem as a city necessarily. It has to grow to be a problem of the people against somebody … So I think there's work to do there.”

    Context: Jordan, who pulled the item, warns that the ordinance leaves an enforcement gap because the City can only act when an individual tenant's problem escalates to a broader public harm.

  • Kristen SneddonCouncilmember (Mayor Pro Tem)January 27, 2026Video · 0:38:29
    “I've been meeting with many housing providers … and have really great ideas including … maybe having a housing provider designation for those who are staying below the 120 AMI or are demonstrating that they're not raising to the maximum. … there could be either maybe some form of financial incentive for that, maybe low interest loans or … a way to address the really real … maintenance costs for the small scale local housing provider.”

    Context: Sneddon floats incentives (low-interest loans, a 'housing provider' designation) for small landlords who stay below 120% AMI, acknowledging their maintenance costs.

  • Kristen SneddonCouncilmember (Mayor Pro Tem)January 27, 2026Video · 0:39:42
    “this very temporary moratorium on increases. I don't really want to call it a rent freeze because we're not freezing rents as has happened in the past. This is just a very temporary moratorium on increases while we can collect and establish all of these really meaningful good ideas to be able to protect the small local small-scale property owners and tenants.”

    Context: Mayor Pro Tem Sneddon distinguishes the measure from a 'rent freeze,' framing it as a temporary pause on increases pending a permanent program.

  • Randy RowseMayorJanuary 27, 2026Video · 0:49:53
    “It's a major economic decision for many of for many in the small business sector, and it's broadly applied without regard to individual circumstances or or consideration. … the rent freeze ordinance represents a strong arm top-down approach, rather than a sincere attempt at approaching the issue with mutual respect and trust for the future of our rental community. Remember that a lot of the rent spikes are the result of government action, not about individual landlord greed. … When 1482 came down the pike, it was precisely when we started spiking rents.”

    Context: Mayor Rowse argues against adopting the moratorium, framing it as a broad economic decision and claiming rent spikes follow government action like AB 1482.

  • Randy RowseMayorJanuary 27, 2026Video · 0:51:41
    “I would ask that we take a pause on this to really understand even the scope of what we're talking about. We do not have the facts. We do not have the data, the number of units, some confusion over what an ADU is, what a granny unit is … And I think the administrative costs of this are so far beyond what we've kind of casually chatted about.”

    Context: Rowse urges colleagues to delay rather than adopt, asserting the City lacks data on affected units and has underestimated administrative costs.

  • Randy RowseMayorJanuary 27, 2026Video · 0:52:26
    “There's a reason why Santa Monica spends $6 million a year. I don't know if we're going to spend that kind of dough, but the other side of the coin is, they're the same same size agency, why are they doing that?”

    Context: Rowse cites Santa Monica's roughly $6M annual rent-program cost as a benchmark for what Santa Barbara may face.

  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberJanuary 27, 2026Video · 0:52:26
    “I agree that we have more our staff has more information to gather about our housing stock, and that's exactly where our rental registry will come in. … the overall larger rent stabilization ordinance, which is not what we're discussing today … this is something that has been shown to work in Alameda, Pasadena, and other cities.”

    Context: Harmon responds to Rowse's data concern by pointing to the planned rental registry and citing other California cities as evidence rent stabilization works.

  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberJanuary 27, 2026Video · 0:54:16
    “this is a temporary increase, and it ends the second that we have a permanent rent stabilization ordinance. … the we're going to sue you threats are getting old … nobody here is seizing property. We are implementing regulations on a business, and we are doing that to stabilize the community.”

    Context: Harmon rebuts the 'no off-ramp' and takings arguments, framing the moratorium as temporary regulation of a business rather than seizure of property.

  • Kelly McAdooCity AdministratorJanuary 13, 2026Video · 6:15:12
    “this particular ordinance um the say today we we don't think it will have a significant cost or staffing impact. It'll be on a complaint basis … that said going forward a more comprehensive rent program will obviously need more resources.”

    Context: McAdoo responds to Jordan's request to anticipate costs, distinguishing the low-cost complaint-based moratorium from the resource-intensive permanent program (and floats using the business-license database as a rental registry).

  • Kristen SneddonCouncilmemberJanuary 13, 2026Video · 6:16:13
    “I want to emphasize that that pause was for the benefit of the mom and pops. It doesn't benefit the tenants. … We took two and a half years pausing and that pause was for the property owners. … and that whole time tenants rents were being raised.”

    Context: Sneddon argues the moratorium ('pause') is necessary because years of delay have only allowed rents to keep rising on tenants.

  • Meagan HarmonCouncilmemberJanuary 13, 2026Video · 6:23:08
    “this action tonight is about good governance. It is about doing policy the right way. … this is about preserving what currently exists so we can have honest, challenging … conversations about how to put together a program that truly serves Santa Barbara. Without this, … our community is at risk, all of our community.”

    Context: Harmon frames the moratorium as preserving the status quo while a permanent rent-stabilization program is developed, and signals she will make or support the motion.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberJanuary 13, 2026Video · 6:27:21
    “I truly don't buy the allegations that if we provide some breathing room to tenants, all of a sudden landlords won't be repairing units because you weren't doing it already. This sounds more like a threat than anything else, and it is simply not good governance for us to be reacting simply to threats.”

    Context: Santamaria rebuts landlord warnings that a rent freeze will reduce maintenance/repairs, citing her experience as a community organizer with deteriorated units.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberJanuary 13, 2026Video · 6:29:25
    “Even if you vote against the permanent rent stabilization ordinance, I do think that every one of you should at the very least support an immediate pause and breathing room for everybody so that we can craft a long-term ordinance with the care and public input that it requires.”

    Context: Santamaria's rationale urging colleagues to back the temporary freeze regardless of their position on the eventual permanent ordinance, and she requests the freeze and just-cause provisions be voted separately.

  • Eric FriedmanCouncilmemberJanuary 13, 2026Video · 6:31:49
    “it does reduce housing supply when you put in these extra restrictions because housing units come off the market. There's not investment in new housing. … It reduces the supply. It reduces the investment. So it reduces the number of jobs that they have available.”

    Context: Friedman, who says he personally had to leave Santa Barbara over rents, explains his no vote on supply-and-investment grounds tied to building-trades jobs.

  • Randy RowseMayorJanuary 13, 2026Video · 6:36:35
    “We don't have the data. We don't even know how many units we're talking about. … we haven't done the the monetary research. We haven't done the physical research that it takes to do something this incredibly impactful in a community. We haven't done it yet.”

    Context: Mayor Rowse's central objection — voting to freeze rents without knowing the number of affected units, landlord expenses, or fiscal/economic effects.

  • Randy RowseMayorJanuary 13, 2026Video · 6:40:17
    “I think it's discriminatory to to one set of landlords out of all the different landlords in this town … this has never worked anywhere. … I spent some time with the the lawyers in Santa Monica. They spend $6 million a year running their program in the same size city.”

    Context: Rowse argues the freeze unfairly targets one sector (pre-1995, Costa-Hawkins-eligible stock) and cites Santa Monica's program cost as evidence rent control is costly and ineffective.

  • Randy RowseMayorJanuary 13, 2026Video · 6:40:17
    “So, I'm not saying we're going to get sued. I'm say we might. I've been told by my attorney this isn't a taking. And uh okay, so taking's got a legal definition. I'm certainly not an attorney, but man, if it it walks and talks like a duck. I mean that is, you know, we're we're basically taking this your properties and freezing them until we decide what to do with them. And I just think that is not responsible.”

    Context: Mayor Rowse explaining his no vote on the temporary rent-increase moratorium (January 13, 2026): despite counsel's advice that the freeze is not a taking, he argues it functions like one — freezing owners' property 'until we decide what to do with them.'

  • Mike JordanCouncilmemberDecember 16, 2025Video · 5:30:56
    “I'm not really happy with anything that links to CPI. So when I do my research on California CPI, there's absolutely nothing in the statistical basis of CPI that has anything to do with the expense loads on investment property… mortgage rates, um taxes, repairs… it's just I think uh it's an oxymoron linking to CPI as a phrase. it it is a contradiction… It's apples to oranges.”

    Context: Jordan's central objection to a CPI-indexed cap, arguing CPI does not track landlord operating costs.

  • Mike JordanCouncilmemberDecember 16, 2025Video · 5:32:30
    “I think the the cost to administer this will be crippling… I don't know where you think the additional costs are going the additional dollars are going to come from to fund this program… I don't see where you see it coming from other than sliding sideways from somebody else's uh social equity or program and service… I don't see any new revenue coming in that will carry the millions of dollars to run this.”

    Context: Jordan warns the program's administrative cost will be 'crippling' to the general fund.

  • Kristen SneddonCouncilmemberDecember 16, 2025Video · 5:58:53
    “this one is beloved to me because it's where I had stability growing up… And yet, it's still profitable, increased in value because it's a constrained market. And where the wealth generated in this property comes from is not from the rents. It's from the increased value of the property just by existing over time.”

    Context: Sneddon's anecdotal case-study argument that rent stabilization preserves landlord profitability because wealth comes from appreciation, not rent.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberDecember 16, 2025Video · 6:23:34
    “the as it stands right now, 5% plus 100% of CPI allows for rents to double within eight years… if you look at a f flat 5% that results in your rent doubling in about 14 years… the proposal that council member said and I have have been proposing would result it the 60% of CPI would result in your rent doubling in 30 years instead of eight. That is significantly more manageable for our city workers…”

    Context: Santamaria's core rationale for a 60%-of-CPI cap, comparing rent-doubling time horizons against the state TPA and a flat 5%.

  • Wendy SantamariaCouncilmemberDecember 16, 2025Video · 6:24:56
    “a fixed percentage alone will not be able to accurately be tied to the cost of living or allow for net operating income needed for a constitutionally required fair right of return… That is the reason why we say 60% of CPI and not 100% of CPI. Federal studies have shown that about 40% of CPI is already accounted for for housing and so counting it as 100% of CPI essentially would make us count the housing category twice.”

    Context: Santamaria's technical justification for the 60% figure, invoking fair-return and the housing share of CPI.

  • Randy RowseMayorDecember 16, 2025Video · 6:43:02
    “the idea that this is not going to be expensive to do is doesn't seem apparent to me tonight. I spent some time with the attorneys from Santa Monica… they spend $6 million a year and they have a 24 person staff that does their rental housing and uh rent control uh program… we're going into this thing… without really a monetary study per se. We have some ideas. We have anecdotes. We have emotion. We have politics. Do we know the number of units?”

    Context: Rowse's principal fiscal/feasibility objection, citing Santa Monica's program cost and the absence of a monetary study.

  • Randy RowseMayorDecember 16, 2025Video · 6:45:33
    “it's amazing to me that we can sit up there with the hubris and say we're going to put the burden of our entire city's affordability for housing on a relatively small sector. Those people with the multifamily units per pre period of 1995… what happens in these markets when we have onerous uh landlord restrictions is you end up diminishing not only the the number of units being produced, you diminish the quality of the the units themselves…”

    Context: Rowse argues rent control burdens a small pre-1995 multifamily sector and degrades supply and quality.

  • Eric FriedmanCouncilmemberDecember 16, 2025Video · 7:01:20
    “I just want to explain my no vote on that is earlier in this discussion felt like it's come to the table. But some of the comments I heard, it feels like they're just completely ignored… it felt like this is just going to get railroaded through. So if it had been a little bit more collaborative during the discussion, I might have voted yes on that.”

    Context: Friedman explains his 'no' vote on the moratorium/Ellis-Act motion, citing a lack of collaboration despite his stated willingness to work across positions.